Natural Picks is reader-supported: when you buy through our Amazon links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. No brand pays to be featured or ranked. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we make money.
The short version
We compared six fluoride-free toothpastes. Davids is the only one where a certifier’s record matches the product, and Tom’s of Maine is the only one whose listing contradicts itself on its main claim. Davids scored 77, Weleda 73, Desert Essence 66, Dr. Bronner’s 64, Tom’s of Maine 63 and hello 54.
This guide covers fluoride-free toothpastes only. Fluoride toothpaste is regulated as an over-the-counter drug, and we do not review drugs. A fluoride-free toothpaste is not a substitute for what fluoride does, and this guide cannot tell you whether to skip it. Ask your dentist. We did not use or test any toothpaste. General information, not medical advice.

Jump to picks · Compare · What to know · How we chose
We searched Amazon.com for fluoride-free natural toothpaste on Oct 27, 2026, read the full listing for six traceable brands and kept one product per brand. We searched CPSC and FDA recall data for each brand and checked the certifications each listing names.
4 of 6
listings print a full ingredient list in their Important information box: Davids, Weleda, Desert Essence and Tom’s of Maine. Dr. Bronner’s names its main ingredients only in the bullets, and hello prints none on the page we read. Counted from the six listings, Oct 27, 2026.
Davids | Weleda Salt | Desert Essence | Dr. Bronner’s | Tom’s of Maine | hello | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Editorial score | 77/1003.9 | 73/1003.7 | 66/1003.3 | 64/1003.2 | 63/1003.2 | 54/1002.7 |
| Best for | Certification you can trace | Ingredient detail | A larger tube | Organic ingredients | A widely sold brand | Not a top pick |
| Size read | 5.25 oz | 3 x 2.5 oz | 6.25 oz | 3 x 5 oz | 2 x 5.5 oz | 3 x 5 oz |
| Certification | EWG Verified record found | NATRUE claimed, not verified | Non-GMO claimed, not checked | Organic and Leaping Bunny claimed | None named | None named |
| Full ingredient list on page | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Lists SLS | No | No | No (has sarcosinate) | No | Yes, despite “SLS free” claim | Not stated |
| Seller | Brand | Amazon.com | Brand’s owner | Brand | Amazon.com | Amazon.com |
| Limitation | “Aggressively stop plaque” wording | NATRUE not verified | Broad “no harmful chemicals” wording | No full ingredient list | SLS contradiction | No ingredients on page |
| Shop | View on Amazon | View on Amazon | View on Amazon | View on Amazon | View on Amazon | View on Amazon |
What to know before you buy
These points come from the listings we read, the records we searched and general information. General advice is marked.
- This guide is fluoride-free only. In the US, toothpaste with fluoride and an anticavity claim is sold as an over-the-counter drug with a Drug Facts label. A fluoride-free toothpaste is sold as a cosmetic and does not carry that claim. We therefore do not rank anything on cavity prevention, and we would not trust a listing that claims it without fluoride. General information, not medical advice.
- Ask your dentist before switching. General advice: many dentists recommend fluoride toothpaste for cavity prevention. Dr. Bronner’s listing says “Most Americans already get fluoride from tap water”, which is a general statement we cannot check for your water. Your dentist can tell you what fits your teeth.
- “Natural” is something to investigate, not a quality rating. Tom’s of Maine says “naturally derived” and lists a synthetic detergent; Weleda says “free from … flavors” and lists “Flavor (Aroma)”. Read the ingredient list, not the front of the tube.
- Abrasivity matters for enamel. General advice: toothpaste abrasives are measured as RDA. Only Davids prints a figure (101). If a listing does not print one, you cannot compare.
- A certification should have a record. We could match Davids to an EWG Verified record. NATRUE, Non-GMO Project, Leaping Bunny and organic claims on the other listings are the makers’ statements until a record is found.
- Children under 6 need adult supervision. General advice from the labels we read: Tom’s of Maine and Desert Essence say to keep the product out of reach of children under 6. For a child’s toothpaste, ask a dentist.

Claims, translated
| Claim | What it covers | Key exclusion |
|---|---|---|
| “EWG Verified” | A product in EWG’s program meets its ingredient and transparency rules | We confirmed the program record for Davids; we did not read its verification date |
| “Certified natural by NATRUE” | A natural-cosmetics label from a trade body | We could not search its database; no certificate number on the listing |
| “SLS free” / “no SLS” | The product has no sodium lauryl sulfate | Check the ingredient list: Tom’s of Maine says it and lists it |
| “Helps prevent tartar buildup” / “crushes tartar” | A cosmetic description of cleaning | No test or number given on either listing |
| “Aggressively stop plaque”, “detox”, “restore healthy pH” | Health-style effects | No study is named; we do not treat them as facts |
| “Without harmful chemicals” / “safe brushing” | A general reassurance | No standard or test is named |
| “70% organic” | Share of ingredients grown organically | No seal number on the listing |
Listings we would be careful with
| Listing | What we found | Our check |
|---|---|---|
| Hydroxyapatite toothpastes that say they “remineralize” or “reverse small cavities” (for example Ollie) | Wording that sounds like a treatment claim for a product sold without fluoride, in some cases in the search-result text itself. | Not scored: drug-style claims |
| NEEM Essential toothpaste (“Cavity Protection”, fluoride-free) | The title promises cavity protection without fluoride; we did not read the listing in full. | Not scored: claim we could not support |
| Unbranded 7.5% to 9.9% nano hydroxyapatite toothpastes (for example Woadee and others) | Brand names we could not trace and strength numbers in the title; no records read. | Not scored: unknown brand |
| Fluoride toothpastes (Tom’s of Maine Whole Care, Crest, Sensodyne and others) | Over-the-counter drugs with a Drug Facts label; outside this guide. | Not scored: out of scope |
Our picks

Best-documented certification
1. Davids Fluoride Free Natural Toothpaste, Peppermint
77/100
Editorial score3.9EWG Verified record found
Full ingredient list
Sold by the brand
| Size read | One 5.25 oz tube in a recyclable metal tube |
| EWG Verified | EWG’s program search (Oct 27, 2026) lists Davids Premium Natural Toothpaste, Natural Peppermint among five EWG Verified Davids toothpastes |
| Ingredients (printed) | Calcium carbonate, vegetable glycerin, water, baking soda, xylitol, hydrated silica, sodium cocoyl glutamate, carrageenan, peppermint, spearmint, anise and wintergreen oils, stevia leaf extract |
| Abrasivity | “RDA of 101 … Safe range per ADA” |
| Claims to read carefully | “Designed to aggressively stop plaque from forming”, “Supports Mouth & Gum Detox”, “restore a healthy PH balance and support your mouth’s natural oral microbiome” |
| Safety text | For external use only; do not swallow; consult a dentist if irritation occurs |
| Recalls | No toothpaste record found for Davids in CPSC or FDA recall data on Oct 27, 2026 |
| Seller | Sold by Davids Health Sciences (the brand) |
| Price | See current price on Amazon |
Davids scored highest because it is the only listing here where a named certifier’s record matches the product. EWG’s Verified program lists “Davids Premium Natural Toothpaste, Natural Peppermint” and the listing prints a full ingredient list, an abrasivity number and a seller we can trace. We could not open EWG’s product page (a bot check blocked it), so we did not read the verification date.
The claims are bigger than the evidence. “Aggressively stop plaque”, “detox” and “restore a healthy PH balance” are statements about health effects with no study named. We score them down and do not repeat them as facts. General information, not medical advice.
Why it scored well
- EWG Verified record found for this product name
- Full ingredient list, abrasivity figure and directions
- Sold by the brand
Watch-outs
- “Aggressively stop plaque” and “detox” wording
- EWG product page not read (bot check)
- Ships-from line not shown in the page text

Best-documented ingredients and certifications
2. Weleda Natural Salt Toothpaste, 3-Pack
73/100
Editorial score3.7Names NATRUE and B Corp
Full ingredient list
Sold by Amazon.com
| Size read | Three 2.5 oz tubes (7.5 oz) |
| Certification claim | “Certified natural by NATRUE” (no certificate number on the listing) |
| Other named programs | Certified B Corporation, TerraCycle recycling, Union for Ethical BioTrade (all from the manufacturer’s A+ text) |
| Ingredients (printed) | Sodium bicarbonate, water, glycerin, silica, peppermint oil, sea salt, jojoba oil, gums, alcohol, myrrh, horse chestnut and ratanhia extracts, “Flavor (Aroma)”, camphor, eucalyptus oil, lavender, menthol and others |
| Claims to read carefully | Extracts “help to tone gums”; sea salt “stimulates salivation increasing the cleaning power” |
| Inconsistencies | Says “free from … flavors” while the list includes “Flavor (Aroma)”; contains alcohol, camphor and eucalyptus oil |
| Safety text | For external use only; do not swallow; consult a dentist if irritation occurs |
| Recalls | No record for Weleda in CPSC data on Oct 27, 2026 |
| Seller | Shipper / Seller: Amazon.com |
| Price | See current price on Amazon |
Weleda’s listing is the most open about what is in the tube and who stands behind it: a full ingredient list, a safety statement, directions and a named natural-cosmetics certification. It is sold by Amazon.com. NATRUE keeps a searchable database, but it sits behind a reCAPTCHA, so we did not search it and call the certification “manufacturer states”, not verified.
Read the ingredient list if you are sensitive to fragrance-type ingredients. It includes camphor, eucalyptus oil, lavender oil, menthol and several fragrance components such as limonene and linalool, and it contains alcohol. “Free from … flavors” does not match “Flavor (Aroma)” on the list. General information, not medical advice.
Why it scored well
- Full ingredient list and safety text
- Names the certifier and other programs
- Sold by Amazon.com
Watch-outs
- NATRUE claim not verified (database behind reCAPTCHA)
- “Free from flavors” vs “Flavor (Aroma)” on the list
- Contains alcohol, camphor and eucalyptus oil

Best for a larger tube
3. Desert Essence Tea Tree Oil and Neem Toothpaste, Wintergreen
66/100
Editorial score3.3Full ingredient list
Non-GMO claim
Sold by the brand’s owner
| Size read | One 6.25 oz tube |
| Certification claim | “Non-GMO Project verified” (we did not check the Non-GMO Project listing) |
| Ingredients (printed) | Calcium carbonate, glycerin, water, tea tree leaf water, sodium lauroyl sarcosinate, carrageenan, wintergreen oil, baking soda, tea tree oil, neem extract, sea salt |
| Claims to read carefully | “Without harmful chemicals, ensuring a safe brushing experience”; neem and tea tree “remove impurities and promote gum health” |
| Safety text | Keep out of reach of children under 6; if swallowed, contact a healthcare provider |
| Recalls | No toothpaste record for Desert Essence in CPSC data on Oct 27, 2026 |
| Seller | Ships from Amazon, sold by Country Life Vitamins; Desert Essence is owned by Country Life, LLC (trademark records), a link the listing does not state |
| Price | See current price on Amazon |
Desert Essence prints a full ingredient list, a swallowing warning and directions, and the seller is its parent company’s storefront. It is the largest tube here (6.25 oz). The ingredient list shows sodium lauroyl sarcosinate, a mild surfactant, so “SLS-free” is accurate but “without harmful chemicals” is a broad phrase with no meaning we can check.
It loses points on certification, since “non-GMO Project verified” came with no number and we did not look it up, and on claims such as “safe brushing experience”. The listing says it is for “cleaning teeth and gums”, which is the modest claim here. General information, not medical advice.
Why it scored well
- Full ingredient list and swallowing warning
- Largest tube here
- Modest stated use: clean teeth and gums
Watch-outs
- “Without harmful chemicals” and “safe brushing experience”
- Non-GMO claim not checked
- Seller relationship not stated on the listing

Best for organic ingredients
4. Dr. Bronner’s Fluoride-Free & SLS-Free Toothpaste, Peppermint
64/100
Editorial score3.270% organic ingredients (claimed)
Leaping Bunny (claimed)
Sold by the brand
| Size read | Three 5 oz tubes (15 oz) |
| Claims | “70% Organic”, fair trade ingredients, “never tested on animals and meet Leaping Bunny standards” (no seal numbers; we did not check them) |
| Ingredients named | Hydrated silica and calcium carbonate (polish), baking soda, potassium cocoate from organic coconut oil, organic essential oils; no full list in the Important information box |
| What it leaves out | No SLS and three other named foaming agents; no artificial colors, flavors or sweeteners |
| About fluoride | “Most Americans already get fluoride from tap water” (a general statement on the listing; see “What to know”) |
| Safety text | For external use only; do not swallow; keep out of reach of children; consult a dentist if irritation occurs |
| Inconsistencies | The title says “No … Mint” on a Peppermint flavor; the legal disclaimer is for dietary supplements |
| Recalls | No record for Dr. Bronner’s in CPSC data on Oct 27, 2026 |
| Seller | Ships from Amazon, sold by Dr. Bronner’s |
| Price | See current price on Amazon |
Dr. Bronner’s is the choice for people who want organic ingredients first: the listing says 70% organic and names the main ones, and it is sold by the brand. It states plainly what it leaves out, including four synthetic foaming agents.
The listing is less complete than the others: it prints no full ingredient list in the Important information box, shows no organic or Leaping Bunny seal number, and the legal text is about dietary supplements, which does not fit a toothpaste. The title’s “No Fluoride, SLS, or Mint” sits next to a Peppermint flavor. General information, not medical advice.
Why it scored well
- Names main ingredients and what it leaves out
- Sold by the brand
- Safety text and directions given
Watch-outs
- No full ingredient list in Important information
- Organic and Leaping Bunny claims have no numbers
- Supplement disclaimer on a toothpaste

Most widely sold, with a listing contradiction
5. Tom’s of Maine Antiplaque and Whitening Toothpaste, Peppermint, 2-Pack
63/100
Editorial score3.2Full ingredient list
Sold by Amazon.com
SLS contradiction
| Size read | Two 5.5 oz tubes (11 oz) |
| Ingredients (printed) | Calcium carbonate, glycerin, water, xylitol, hydrated silica, natural flavor (peppermint oil), zinc citrate, sodium lauryl sulfate, carrageenan, baking soda |
| Contradiction | The bullets and the title say “SLS free”, and the ingredient list prints sodium lauryl sulfate |
| Claims | “Helps prevent tartar buildup with regular brushing”; “naturally sourced and naturally derived ingredients”; no certification named |
| Warnings | Keep out of reach of children under 6 |
| Recalls | No toothpaste record for Tom’s of Maine in CPSC data on Oct 27, 2026 |
| Seller | Shipper / Seller: Amazon.com |
| Price | See current price on Amazon |
Tom’s of Maine is a widely sold brand, the listing prints a full ingredient list and it is sold by Amazon.com. It names no certification, so there was nothing to check.
The listing contradicts itself on its own headline claim. The bullets call it an “SLS free toothpaste” and the title lists “SLS-Free”, and the printed ingredient list shows sodium lauryl sulfate. We cannot tell from the listing which text is out of date, so read the tube. We score it down for the mismatch, not for the ingredient. General information, not medical advice.
Why it scored well
- Full ingredient list and warning
- Sold by Amazon.com
- Widely sold, long-standing brand
Watch-outs
- “SLS free” claim contradicted by its own ingredient list
- No certification named
- Tartar claim has no data

Least information on the page
6. hello Antiplaque and Whitening Fluoride Free Toothpaste, 3-Pack
54/100
Editorial score2.7Sold by Amazon.com
Made by Colgate-Palmolive
No ingredient list on this page
| Size read | Three 5 oz tubes (15 oz) |
| Claims | “Naturally whitens with friendly minerals”, “farm grown peppermint”, “crushes tartar”; “no SLS, peroxide, dyes, parabens, artificial sweeteners or flavors, titanium dioxide” |
| Ingredients | Not printed on this listing; the Important information box holds only directions and a dietary-supplement disclaimer |
| Certification | None named |
| Recalls | No fluoride-free hello record found; an FDA record from 2023 covers a label mix-up on a different product, hello wild strawberry fluoride toothpaste |
| Seller | Shipper / Seller: Amazon.com |
| Price | See current price on Amazon |
hello is sold by Amazon.com and made by Colgate-Palmolive, which is why it passes the reliability check. The page we read, though, prints no ingredient list and no warnings, so every “no SLS” or “natural” claim cannot be checked against the tube from the listing.
Its sister listing for the 4.7 oz three-pack does print an ingredient list but has no buy box, so we did not use it. Treat the claims as the maker’s statements and read the tube. General information, not medical advice.
Why it scored well
- Sold by Amazon.com
- Made by a known manufacturer
- Clear statement of what it leaves out
Watch-outs
- No ingredient list or warnings on this page
- No certification named
- “Crushes tartar” wording with no data
Why no score above 77? No listing names a certificate number, only one matches a certifier record, and most make claims that go past what the label states. The scores reflect the records and what the sellers put in writing, not how well each toothpaste cleans, how it tastes or how it feels.
How to choose a fluoride-free toothpaste
- Decide with your dentist first. General advice: if you are choosing fluoride-free for a reason, ask whether that fits your teeth.
- Read the ingredient list. Compare the list with the claims on the front. Four of our six listings print one.
- Look for a number or a record. An RDA figure, a certificate number or a certifier record beats an adjective.
- Check your own sensitivities. Essential oils, menthol, camphor and fragrance components are common in natural pastes, and the Weleda list includes several.
- Be wary of cavity wording. A fluoride-free paste that promises to stop or reverse cavities is making a drug-style claim.
- Buy from a seller you can trace. Four of our picks are sold by Amazon.com or the brand, and one by the brand’s parent company.

How this guide was researched
We searched Amazon.com for fluoride-free natural toothpaste on Oct 27, 2026, kept one product per brand and read each full listing (title, bullets, A+ text, the Important information box, product details and the seller line, with a US delivery ZIP code). We searched CPSC and FDA recall data for each brand and looked for the certifications each listing names. We scored products with our published method: provenance and certification (25), disclosure (20), claims (20), consistency (10) and seller (15); value is left out because no live price data was available. We did not use or test any toothpaste.
Limits: the NATRUE database and EWG’s product page were blocked by bot checks and were not read. We did not look up the Non-GMO Project, Leaping Bunny, USDA organic or ADA Seal records. FDA recall data lists fluoride toothpastes, which are drugs, so a missing record is not proof of a clean history. Scope is fluoride-free toothpaste only. Research mode: research-based comparison. General information, not medical advice.
Common questions
What is the best natural toothpaste?
On the records and what the listings state, Davids scored 77, Weleda 73, Desert Essence 66, Dr. Bronner’s 64, Tom’s of Maine 63 and hello 54. We did not test them, and these scores say nothing about cavity prevention.
Is fluoride-free toothpaste as good as fluoride toothpaste?
We cannot say. Fluoride toothpaste is an over-the-counter drug, and we do not review drugs. Ask your dentist. General information, not medical advice.
Why does this guide skip fluoride toothpaste?
In the US, fluoride toothpaste with an anticavity claim is regulated as an over-the-counter drug. Our site does not review drugs.
Is Tom’s of Maine SLS free?
The listing says so in its bullets and title, and its ingredient list prints sodium lauryl sulfate. Check the tube you receive.
What does EWG Verified mean?
EWG’s program checks a product’s ingredients against its own standards. We found a record for Davids Natural Peppermint but could not open EWG’s product page to read the date.
Is the NATRUE claim on Weleda verified?
Not by us. NATRUE’s database is behind a reCAPTCHA, so we treat the claim as the maker’s statement.
What does RDA mean on toothpaste?
Relative dentin abrasivity, a standard measure of how abrasive a paste is. Davids prints 101; the others print none.
Are hydroxyapatite toothpastes in this guide?
No. We set aside the ones that claim to remineralize or reverse cavities, and the unbranded ones, as drug-style or untraceable. See the careful-with table.
Can children use these?
Check the label. Tom’s of Maine and Desert Essence say to keep the product away from children under 6, and hello says to supervise children under 6. Ask a dentist about a child’s toothpaste.
Why does one listing have no ingredient list?
The hello page we read prints only directions and a dietary-supplement disclaimer. Another hello listing prints a list but had no buy box, so we did not use it.
Are essential oils a concern?
They can irritate some people. General advice: read the list and stop using a paste if your mouth is irritated. General information, not medical advice.
How long does a tube last?
The listings give sizes, not use times. Sizes we read range from 2.5 oz to 6.25 oz per tube.







